A swarm of internet nasties descended on Laila Alawa, an American Muslim writer, publisher and activist, after she was targeted last week as public enemy #1 by an assortment of right-wing sites — starting with The Daily Caller then spreading to assorted even more fringey sites from JihadWatch to PamelaGeller.com.
Alawa’s most horrendous crime, in the minds of her attackers? She once tweeted that the 9/11 attacks permanently changed the world.
No, really. Here’s the tweet that triggered the onslaught of Internet harassment that’s made Alawa’s life a living hell:
You may notice that she did not say that 9/11 changed the world “for the better.” She said “for good,” a phrase that everyone with even a rudimentary grasp of English should know means “permanently.”
But somehow every right-wing Muslim-hater who saw the Daily Caller post that launched this wave of hate decided that she was praising the terrorist attacks on 9/11/2001 in that tweet. Adding to their indignation: the fact that Alawa had participated in the making of a recently issued Department of Homeland Security report on violent extremism.
Professional Islamaphobe Pamela Geller gave her post on the subject this absurd headline:
Freedom Daily meanwhile, declared:
A site called The Political Insider offered a similarly twisted misreading of Alawa’s tweet; the site also managed to transform her work last year with the Department of Homeland Security into a direct appointment by Obama after the Orlando massacre.
Within a few days, there was so much nonsense about Alawa floating around the internet that the urban legend-busting site Snopes.com felt obliged to weigh in with a lengthy rebuttal of the most outrageous false claims, leading the author of the Daily Caller piece to attack the author of the Snopes.com piece as a “failed liberal blogger.”
As assorted right-wing websites and blogs fanned the flames, a virtual army of the internet’s worst people descended on Alawa, flooding her Twitter and Facebook mentions with an assortment of angry and threatening messages.
“On Tuesday, June 14, 2016, I woke up to a hell that even I could not have predicted,” Alawa wrote yesterday in a post on The Tempest, an online publication she founded and runs. “Hundreds of people were tweeting at me, the vitriol, hatred and fury in their messages each worse than the last one.”
Here are some of the messages she collected, one of which I’ve lightly censored:
This fellow gave Alawa a promotion to the top job at Homeland Security:
This fellow showed that he actually does know the difference between “for good” and “for the better” — unless the person using the phrase “for good” is Muslim.
And this lovely lady tossed in a plug for Donald Trump after wishing Alawa a gruesome death:
Meanwhile, this familiar face did his part to spread the Daily Caller’s blatant misinformation:
And all of this because a “reporter” at The Daily Caller searched through at least two years of her tweets in order to find a “smoking gun” tweet that turned out to be neither smoking nor a gun.
In her post on The Tempest, Alawa put the tweet that offended the world in context:
“Just like every American, 9/11 was a tragedy that hit close to home,” she wrote.
I was 10 when it happened, living in upstate New York, and the event and ensuing aftermath left me – and the nation – reeling. So much so that it changed my career path for good – I now fight to ensure that every woman, no matter who or where or how she is, has a media outlet to find a space in. So in 2014, upon the anniversary of the attacks, I sent out a tweet, like I do every year, about the events that had transpired.
She explained the difference between “for good” and “for the better,” knowing full well that it wouldn’t make any difference to
the thousands and thousands of people taking it upon themselves to comb through my private history, any public articles I had written, any photos I had online.
She recounted the abuse she’d gotten over the past week:
I received rape threats, death threats, and images that made me almost throw up. People, furious and filled with a hatred against someone they didn’t even know, had decided I was the perfect target for the entire week.
I couldn’t sleep. I couldn’t eat. Each morning, I’d wake up, and suddenly remember what was happening online, and want to go back to sleep. All I could do was numbly block and report, block and report. … I kept laughing when I told the story in public, because if I stopped, I knew I’d start crying. I’d step away from my phone for 5 minutes, and come back to a hundred notifications.
People told her it would get better.
It didn’t get better. It still hasn’t gotten better. I’m now enemy #1 of racist, conservative, Trump-loving America, the favorite obsession of white supremacists and “patriots,” clickbait for every possible conservative platform and bigots like Pamela Geller, Allen West, and Milo Yannoupolis.
The bitter irony at the heart of all this hate? These abusive, vicious, barbaric right-wing bigots have somehow managed to convince themselves and their followers that they’re the ones defending Western civilization from barbarism.
H/T to Orion Anderson for sending me Alawa’s post.
@Lars
Highlight of mine is watching people like you make asses of themselves here. But hey, I don’t watch TV, so there’s that. Pretty sure GoT has better written dialogues.
http://i.imgur.com/wJYskw0.png
@ktoryx
” Because the idea that a professional writer who has worked for the department of homeland security actually believed that 9/11 was a great thing AND was stupid enough to say it in a fucking TWEET from an account openly bearing her name just beggars the imagination”
You’re forgetting that these people think that the federal government is a communist conspiracy intended to turn them into gay atheists
@Hippie Lady, @Steampunked
Thanks for encouraging us to tweet our supportive messages to Laila Alawa.
Laila Alawa Retweeted Kat K
Thank you so much for sharing. This story was done wonderfully.
Laila Alawa added,
Kat K @KatK14
@lulainlife
http://WeHuntedtheMammoth.com has a story on you. I’m so, so sorry that you’re being harassed! Stay strong!
0 retweets 4 likes
Alternative suggestions for manosphere pokémon:
Wartortle
Farfetch’d
Weezing
Mr. Mime
Ditto
Quagsire
Shuckle
Piloswine
Smeargle
Swampert
Ludicolo
Shiftry
Slaking
Loudred/Exploud
Aggron
Grumpig
Metagross
Infernape
Stunky
Mime Jr.
Toxicroak
Mantyke
Pignite
Scraggy
Trubbish
Klinklang
Golurk
Spewpa
Skrelp
Tyrantrum
Or, perhaps, Zubat.
http://i.imgur.com/YtdWb9x.jpg
@SFHC
Hahahahahaha. That’s the truest thing I’ve ever seen.
@IP
Ditto is totally the official Pokemon of #NotYourShield.
“ANGRY WHITE DUDE transformed into BLACK TRANS LESBIAN!”
@SFHC
“MISOGYNIST MANCHILD’s Racist Override made it suddenly care about sexual assault!”
Hey, the WTC towers could’ve been built with extremely strong armor plates just in case someone decides to fly an airplane in them. Especially since they were going to be American national landmarks.
The reality is the world has people trying to figure out totally unexpected ways to attack American people and the national sense of safety, looking for a weak target among myriad potential targets. Of course that’s unfair but I’m just pointing out a weakness in WTC safety engineering.
I love how Lars feels free to chastise Alawa for not using precisely the wording he himself would have meticulously chosen in that situation, being the finicky connoisseur of English that he is. Then he flies off the handle when someone calls him out for using a genuinely sloppy turn of phrase.
How dare we! White men aren’t supposed to have their language policed! Oppressive PC culture!
I saw a tiny news story that made me smile. A pregnant trans man in Sweden was denied a specific “pregnancy insurance” by a large insurance company, since they refused to sign that particular kind of insurance for a person with a male-coded social security number. The company has now been found guilty of discrimination based on gender, and the man has been awarded $6000 in damages.
Great victory for the Men’s Human Rights Movement, right? AVfM should have a story on this, right? 🙂
@Buttercup Q. Skullpants
Impressive are the privileges of Lars, our Linguist Overlord.
Less impressive: his writing.
And now I’m trying to think where I’ve heard the name Lars before. Of course! On The Mary Tyler Moore Show. Lars was Phyllis’s dentist husband.
But Lars was only discussed. He was never seen or heard from. Maybe this Lars could model himself after the earlier Lars.
Also, as others have noted, this is just a variation on “if she didn’t want to get raped, she shouldn’t have worn that”.
The problem with saying “if you don’t want to get attacked, then don’t say X” is that X is completely arbitrary, and defined by the attacker. If it’s not one X, they’ll find another. And another X, and another X, until there are so many rules for women to go out in public and speak in front of others that they just give up. Even if a woman carefully follows all those rules to the letter, they’ll just find a weaker gazelle to attack.
We need to teach men not to be predatory, instead of teaching women to be better gazelles.
Edit: @Kat – ha! I had forgotten about the mentioned-but-never-seen Lars. If only all our trolls would follow suit.
@kupo, such wonderful brain bleach; thank you 🙂
Jebus! (as Homer would say). What a week…
@IP
A WILD LARS APPEARED
LARS used Snide, Victim Blamey Bullshit, but it failed
COMMENTERS used Bye Felicia, but he couldn’t take a hint
LARS used Brine, he’s extra salty
COMMENTERS used Bruh…
LARS used Substitute. Another Email took the attack
LARS used Creepy Stalking w/ Semipersonal Info, he’s a tool
COMMENTERS used OTP, Savageness sharply increased
LARS used Quit Picking On Me, everyone had a nice chuckle about that
COMMENTERS used Subject Change, Voltron and Pokemon
LARS dipped, many didn’t even really notice til just now
COMMENTERS only gained a little Exp, Lv10s will do that
Re: Misogymon
http://66.media.tumblr.com/a4c99e891465f7aca640dd25244f9b61/tumblr_nsbyowCHWM1tkiv14o5_500.gif
Owngoaling is a staple of these jokers
Teaching men not to be predators is MISANDRY! And probably a freeze peach offense to boot.
A Trump supporter blocked my cat on Twitter for linking to the definition of the expression “for good”. :p
How brave they are.
@IP
This is the entire internet, contained in one sentence.
@Buttercup
Haha. Put this on a t-shirt?
I just tweeted a nicer tweet to Alawa, thank you to whoever suggested that. Hopefully we can offset the hateful deluge she’s getting with something nicer!
As for @Lars, well. “She should have worded it better” is the same as “She shouldn’t have been wearing that dress,” “she shouldn’t have been walking on that street,” “she shouldn’t have been flirting with me,” and “she shouldn’t have been drinking.” These jerks need to approach the world with a modicum of charity in their hearts.
@Scildfreja But that would be MISANDRY!! and EMACIL-EMASK- TURNING ME INTO A MANGINA!
She is also asking people to help get her own piece and or the interview with her on CNNmoney to the top of Google
If individual Muslim women were to avoid saying anything that could possibly be read maliciously by people who hate them and want to flood them with racist and islamophobic abuse, no doubt those individual women would probably face less targeted harassment. Of course, as the growth and spread of this non-story clearly shows, there many people out there who are absolutely gagging themselves for the opportunity to warp anything a Muslim woman says into something she can be targeted for. Essentially, you’re asking Muslim women to never say anything about any sort of sensitive topics, and to do a great deal more labour than the rest of us when discussing something as innocuous as the weather.
The end result is that the women who follow the advice of the Larses of the world will be stifled or silenced altogether, while their harrasers are still permitted to speak freely about whatever they choose. And for what? So that they can potentially* avoid specific, targeted abuse. However, they can still expect to be victims of the oppression directed at their entire community, because “sit down, shut up and hope nobody singles you out” does nothing to change racist and islamophobic attitudes. In fact, these women will be worse off there, because they will no longer have a voice with which to name and fight their own oppression. Furthermore, the overall amount of targeted harassment won’t change. It will just be directed at different women, women who weren’t quite as painstakingly careful with their words.
Lars’ comment isn’t a solution. It’s a silencing tactic. It’s a way of shifting blame.
*I say “potentially,” because racists don’t always bother to wait for an excuse to target someone.
If we at Pavlov’s House said Barbarossa changed the world for good, even if people got in a tither we might be slightly happy just that they knew enough to get the reference. But neither I nor Ms. Pavlov’s House uses Twitter.
Then again, our side won in the end.
Kudos to this little community, we value your anti-fascist ways. When the
Manospherians (Manosweirdians?) say something about military history and David responds, we’ll be back if ye Mammothteers shall have us.