Categories
anti-antifa AntiFa harassment twitter

Nazis are circulating a list of “Antifa” accounts to mass report on Twitter. I’m on the list. So are Joe Biden, the CDC, Jorts the Cat, and Britney Spears

Antifa Britney Spears

So activists on the far right are distributing a list of 5000 “Antifa” Twitter accounts they hope to mass report and get banned, not for breaking any Twitter rules, but just because they want to silence everyone who disagrees with them.

If you peruse the list, you’ll run across not only a wide assortment of Antifa accounts but also those of many liberal and lefty journalists who report on the rising fascist movement, including me. You’ll also find more than a few incongruous names, including Barack Obama, Jorts the Cat, and Britney Spears.

You see, the list was apparently put together by scraping and combining the “following” lists of several activists on the left. But whoever put the list together doesn’t seem to have done any editing of the names to make sure they’re really Antifa or even vaguely political.

Those who made the list include Cardi B, Danny DeVito, Dog_rates, Infinite_scream, KidsWriteJokes, LilNasX, Monica Lewinsky, Sesame Street, the Sierra Club, and dril. There are several accounts that post nothing but pictures of cats and one that only posts alligators. There are also various government agencies, from the CDC to the FBI, the CIA, and the city government of Malibu, California, none of which are hotbeds of Antifa to the best of my knowledge. The strangest inclusion is probably LibsOfTikTok, a notorious right-wing account known for targeting trans people and drag queens.

Gwen Snyder, apparently one of those whose “following” list was scraped, posted a useful Twitter thread that helped put the list in perspective. She pointed out that the list is probably too big and sloppily put together to be used for a mass reporting campaign. But more carefully edited lists could follow, without all the extraneous names, and if even one of those gets into the hands of Elon Musk, he could very easily ban everyone on them.

Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
(Thread)

So, again, it looks like whoever made that "antifa" mass report list directly scraped my following list here for it.

I'm trying to keep making sure folks know because I follow a lot of people not part of explicitly antifascist community, and it's important that people
11:57 AM · Nov 25, 2022
·Twitter for Android
128
 Retweets
14
 Quote Tweets
427
 Likes

Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
Replying to 
@gwensnyderPHL
have the correct context for WHY they are on this list.

Because it is scary and confusing.

So here are few things important to know:
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
1) along with antifascists, I follow a lot of folks from:

- Philly

- neurodivergent and especially ADHD community

- indigenous and especially Hawaiian community

- unions

- queer community

- disabled/COVID-cautious community

- joke Twitter

- academic Twitter, eclectically
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
So, 2) if you fall into these categories (or don't, but I follow you)-- please know that while this is concerning and upsetting, you're very likely on this list because a Nazi was too lazy to sort through my list and figure out who was actually antifascist
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
3) the list is I think 5k people and I only follow around 1.3k, so obviously it isn't *just* my list, they must have scraped several accounts for this.

That said, we have every reason to believe they used the same M.O. across account scrapes.
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
4) that size of list is IMPOSSIBLE to run a mass targeting campaign from. It is simply too large.

They usually pick one or a handful of targets.

I know, because I have been a target many times AND bc I have run effective targeted deplatforming campaigns against Nazis myself.
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
5) what that means functionally is, even if you are on the list, you almost certainly don't need to lock unless you have recieved other intel suggesting you're the subject of more focused, targeted report/harass work.
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
6) I've heard people say ignore this "antifa" target list, it's unimportant, and no, that is not the case.

It is ALWAYS newsworthy and important when Nazis make lists of enemies to attack, even when those lists are (currently) not very effective tactics.
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
What's particularly worrisome right now is, it just takes one person to get this "antifa" list in Elon's grubby little credulous hands.

Locked or not, he'd be able to mass remove those accounts.

Antifascists and collaterals, he won't care.
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
I don't think *this* list is going to make it that far, but this list IS a step in that direction and almost certainly will be followed by copycats.

If the entire far right starts throwing these around as Hail Marys... well, he only has to catch one.
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
So there's not a ton of "people on this list are all going to get mass reported and banned today" danger, simply because this is likely too much of a junk list even for Elon (Biden and Cardi B aree on it, lol), & because a list of 5k people is too long to mass report effectively.
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
At the same time, that isn't to say there's NO danger here, only that the danger posed by *this* list to individuals listed is minimal relative to what we usually see from Nazi report campaigns.

The BIGGER danger is that more sophisticated lists follow & make their way to Elon.
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
These are the actual big dangers this list has created:

- risk of Elon cribbing a similar list in the future and using it for bans, and

- risk of harassment for marginalized folks listed, esp folks who avoid engagement with overtly antifascist content/issues for self-protection
Gwen Snyder is on Mastodon
@gwensnyderPHL
·
9h
I see all these Black, queer, and/or disabled folks who ended up on this list because I followed them, and here they are roped into this circus of fear.

That's what really infuriates me here.

So I guess I’ll unlock my account, at least for now. But given Musk’s actions on Twitter so far, many of which have been directly or indirectly inspired by far-right posters, I’m not optimistic that my account will last much longer.

If you’re on Mastodon, well, so am I.

Follow me on Mastodon.

Send tips to dfutrelle at gmail dot com.

We Hunted the Mammoth relies on support from you, its readers, to survive. So please donate here if you can, or at David-Futrelle-1 on Venmo.

12 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Anonymous
Anonymous
1 year ago

A word of warning, it’s perfectly possible Musk or his cronies will actually listen to them. I know that an anarchist organization that I follow reported that Andy Ngo (you might remember him, the douchebag obsessed with Antifa who got a milkshake to the face once) was able to get them banned despite their never actually breaking any rules.

So expect the worst. Me, I’m lucky because I never had a Twitter account to begin with and don’t plan to start now.

epitome of incomprehensibility

Very free-speechy.

The strangest inclusion is probably LibsOfTikTok, a notorious right-wing account known for targeting trans people and drag queens.

It’s possible that other targeted accounts follow them, just going by what Gwen Snyder wrote. Or maybe the word “libs” was a search term? (Funny if so.)

Snowberry
Snowberry
1 year ago

There are those who say that you’re not truly an antifa until a right-winger calls you one, so congrats to you David, for your official promotion to antifa.

Skiriki
Skiriki
1 year ago

I’m just going to add a caveat that automated, bot-based reporting is also possible and it is possible to make it look organic enough, if the bot coder can settle with “it keeps random time between reports and take several days to do it” rather than “all at once right nowwww”.

Jono
Jono
1 year ago

Those far right-wingers on Twitter were previously “praising” Elon Musk for restoring “free speech” to them. As we all know though, a lot of people who claim to be anti-censorship are only against being censored themselves and if put in charge, would gladly censor others. We’ll see though, despite the high uptick in hate speech on Twitter since he took over as CEO and his unbanning of some hate-mongers, he still apparently claims that hate speech is still not allowed on Twitter and that the TOS hasn’t really changed. So I’m not entirely sure at this point that he’d go so far as start banning people who actively speak out against hate speech without breaking any other rules (besides, there will absolutely no advertisers left on the platform if this happens because all the remaining ones who haven’t left already would also leave).

Ada Christine
Ada Christine
1 year ago

the freest of speech

Thomas James
Thomas James
1 year ago

They, Twitter, have already removed, or seemed to remove, a metric funt ton of Palestinian and Palestinian rights accounts. This is hardly a surprise. Musk and the Nazis are not so slowly turning Twitter into a shittier rip off of Parler or Gab.

runsinbackground
runsinbackground
1 year ago

Wait hold on, Nazi Twitter doesn’t like dril? Say it ain’t so, joe!

Nequam
Nequam
1 year ago

I’m reminded of Nixon’s Enemies List, but extra stupid.

Nathan Tyree
1 year ago

Dril and the CIA are on the list. It breaks my heart that I didn’t make the cut.

Sheila
1 year ago

I’m @starlady on Mastadon. Anyone else care to leave their handle here?

GSS ex-noob
GSS ex-noob
1 year ago

Jorts is openly antifa and a great friend to organized labor, but We Rate Dogs is just pictures of cute doggos! And what about Kids Write Jokes? Won’t they think of the chiiiillldren? I don’t think dril has a political idea in his/her/their head.

Meanwhile, the FBI and *especially* the CIA are totally Fa. Malibu is full of rich white NIMBYs, so definitely not about to overthrow corporate capitalism.

I don’t know Britney’s politics. Considering how the courts treated her, I’m guessing she’s not big on fascism. Mostly she seems to be about getting her life back to normal.

@Jono: At least “Truth”Social is upfront about their ideology, not claiming they welcome everyone and punish hate speech.

@Thomas: Because the only thing fascists hate more than PoC and Jews is Muslims.

@Nequam: DOUBLE extra stupid. Even Nixon liked dogs and didn’t put them on his list. He probably would have enjoyed dog_rates on the whole.