Categories
#GetWokeGoBroke cancel culture playing the victim scott adams

Scott Adams implies Dilbert was “cancelled” in 77 papers for taking on “woke” corporations. But the papers also dumped Blondie, Mr. Boffo, The Family Circus, and Ziggy

Where he belongs

Yesterday, Scott Adams the Dilbert Guy brought us some truly tragic news:

The tragedy? That the strip hasn’t been shitcanned by all the other papers that still run it.

In another tweet, Adams strongly hinted that his alleged “cancellation” was a response to recent comics he did taking aim at ESG — not the legendary Bronx-based all-female punk-funk band but rather an assortment of “woke” corporate practices designed to improve a company’s approach to “Environmental, Social, and Governance” issues. In a video last week, Adams declared that he was going to “destroy ESG.”

Also, he introduced a black character who — get this! — “identifies as white!”

Such a barrel of laughs, this guy.

Anyway, while some in the media and amongst Adams’ fans accepted the “cancellation because woke” narrative wholesale, it turns out to not be true: the “cancellation” was not so much a political statement as it was a consequence of a cost-cutting measure taken by the newspapers’ extremally, er, frugal owners, Lee Enterprises, that also took down an assortment of other comic strips, among them (deep breath) Brewster Rocket: Space Guy!, Sally Forth, Blondie, Shoe, Beetle Bailey, Snuffy Smith, Bizarro, Zits, Breaking Cat News, Judge Parker, Dennis the Menace, The Family Circus, Mr. Boffo, Baby Blues, Mutts and Ziggy.

You’ll be glad to know that Garfield survived the culling that will leave each newspaper in Lee Enterprise’s stable with the same ten comic strips. I don’t think I’ve read a Beetle Bailey in literally decades, and I’ve never heard of Breaking Cat News, but I can’t believe they’re getting rid of Mutts and Mr. Boffo, they both rock (insofar as any newspaper comic strip rocks these days).

Lee Enterprises also reportedly plans to fire about 400 employees from a number of its papers this year, because that’s just the kind of company they are.

Anyway, a bunch of people did Scott Adams one better by posting things on Twitter about Dilbert’s “cancellation” that were actually funny.

https://twitter.com/hellenkeniford/status/1572620345617846274
https://twitter.com/Brendelbored/status/1572386646041198592

If you need me, I’ll be off reading Pharmaduke.

Follow me on Mastodon.

Send tips to dfutrelle at gmail dot com.

We Hunted the Mammoth relies on support from you, its readers, to survive. So please donate here if you can, or at David-Futrelle-1 on Venmo.

41 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Alan Robertshaw
2 years ago

Ironically it’s pretty much down to 1930s Germany that there is a Hollywood. Just check out how many refugees ended up working in the US film industry.

GSS ex-noob
GSS ex-noob
2 years ago

I agree, the Dilbert TV show was better than the strip. More focused, and that great theme song.

Crip Dyke
2 years ago

I never watched the Dilbert TV show. Now that y’all recommend it, though, it’s a bit too late since if I found it on Youtube or something it would give money to this guy.

Lumipuna
Lumipuna
2 years ago

And I remember the mud of Elbonia

(Spoken like an Elbonian immigrant in a nostalgic moment)

Snowberry
Snowberry
2 years ago

1999? Well, that helps narrow down when I last read newspaper comics. I know it must have been before 2002, and I’m 95% certain it was before the Dilbert cartoon aired. Incidentally, I only saw two episodes. Don’t really remember much, mainly that it wasn’t to my tastes.

Surplus to Requirements
Surplus to Requirements
2 years ago

@Crip Dyke:

Two words: ad blocker.

@various:

It seems that it’s World Capitalist Bullshit Week or something, though I was never notified. But all of the following have happened recently, involving deceptive practices by large business entities, most of which don’t make a whole lot of sense:

  1. Today I encountered at least two instances of TV stations using deceptive means to draw attention back to the TV before an advertisement. One was a false “This program contains scenes of violence (or whatever). Viewer discretion is advised.” followed by an ad rather than a segment of show. The second was similar: a false “This program is available with described video for the visually impaired.” People react to those by returning from the kitchen or putting down their phone Solitaire game and paying attention to the TV again, and they exploited that dishonestly.
  2. Several TV stations are likewise mislabeling reruns as “new” this week in a presumed dishonest effort to goose ratings. On Tuesday one aired a repeat of last season’s “Superman” season premiere and labeled it as “New. Season Premiere.”; it was actually the season 2 premiere, not as implied the season 3 premiere (which either I’ve missed or it hasn’t actually aired yet); today, one aired last season’s CSI season finale as “New. Season Premiere.”
  3. The cashiers at the grocery store here persist in asking if you want a bag, and then starting to shove the scanned items into one of theirs even if you said “no”; why ask the question if they’re going to ignore the answer? They also always prompt you if you want air miles, as if there was still a large middle class and J. Random Customer was probably getting on planes every few months for various purposes. I don’t know if this is just inertia (hey, it’s not the 1990s anymore, maybe 5 to 10% of the people can afford to fly and/or have jobs that fly them places now, and a solid 80+% not only can’t afford to but have no realistic prospect of ever affording to!) or if there’s a sinister propaganda purpose behind it (e.g. gaslighting everyone into thinking it’s just them who’s poor, and therefore it’s because of a personal failing that they have no use for air miles, don’t look at us or our multi-billionaire owners). It’s harder to explain the bag thing that way, though. Note: This item isn’t unique to this week, but it has continued into it. The deceptive element is asking one question as if the answer might affect anything, when they have every intention of simply ignoring it, and asking another the mere asking of which implies things about the economy that haven’t actually been true since 2008, if not longer still.
  4. A fast food place near here had, in essence, a fake cashier. There are three registers, of which two were not in use and there was a young man standing behind the third, facing across the counter. I of course walked to this one and began to order a meal, only for him to say nothing that made any sense in response. I repeated myself and he gestured at a headset he was wearing — he was not just wearing a hands-free phone but, apparently, using it. Instead of serving customers. While standing behind the only open register. It’s not like they were even short-staffed; the place was full of employees, if anything an excessive number bustling around in the kitchen and between it and the registers. Phone Guy should have been elsewhere (even outside on the sidewalk if necessary to make room for the rest) and someone else should have been operating (not just standing at, but actually operating) at least one register. There was no need to have that one guy multitask — and indeed he wasn’t, as I never saw him take anyone’s order at that register. Eventually another employee noticed the problem, opened a second register, and took my order there. Until then, not only did it look to customers like Phone Guy’s register was open (and, moreover, the only one open), but it must have looked like that to the other employees too, and it wasn’t hugely busy, so they must have thought there was no need to open a “second” register … This deception seems thoroughly counterproductive even from a greedy-capitalist standpoint, so it’s probably a mistake that stemmed from some sort of cost-cutting measure that backfired on them, compounded by a clueless employee picking the worst place to stand while yakking on the phone likely due to obliviousness to his surroundings. Clearly the workforce was poorly coordinated, given they didn’t seem to realize that for a good ten minutes no one was actually accepting customer orders at the registers at all, smack dab in the middle of dinner hour. That’s got to have cost them a few actual orders and rather a lot more customer goodwill. The same place had an even more bizarre screwup a couple of weeks ago where one employee, or person in an employee uniform, locked one of the two customer entrance doors and stood near the other proclaiming the place to be closed, even though the place was full of customers and the drive-through was turning a brisk business and it was seven- or eight-something and their stated hours are 10 am to 10 pm. The other employees were acting as if it was business as usual, and served anyone who ignored the one and strolled in through the unlocked door. It’s like they were in a state of disagreement among themselves regarding what time of day it was and furthermore made no effort to get on the same page at all (say, by consulting a clock?) … I’m wondering where I’m going to eat (other than at home) now, as that place is clearly going to hell in a handcart, the KFC down the block still hasn’t reopened its dining area post-COVID, and the good-burger joint is a bit more expensive and a significantly longer hike to reach so I can’t go there at all often. Sadly, the one whose management and workforce are increasingly incoherent is also the best-fries one in town …

Incidentally, is anyone else getting a lot of phantom new-mail notifications lately, only to find their inbox empty when they actually pull up the relevant window?

Fabe
Fabe
2 years ago

I never watched the Dilbert TV show. Now that y’all recommend it, though, it’s a bit too late since if I found it on Youtube or something it would give money to this guy.

Plenty of episodes on youtube that I’m pretty sure aren’t there officially. You can watch those with out a dime going to Adams.

Nequam
Nequam
2 years ago

I don’t remember the Dilbert show much tbh except for its opening theme, and I already *have* the soundtrack to Forbidden Zone!

griffon8
griffon8
2 years ago

The amount of projection in Scott’s “How to spot NPCs” is amazing. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Alan Robertshaw
2 years ago

@ surplus

compounded by a clueless employee picking the worst place to stand while yakking on the phone

I’m very much on the side of the employee in circumstances like this. Whilst it’s always nice to get efficient and pleasant service, staff are often treated so appallingly, especially in things like fast food franchises, that I don’t blame them for swinging the lead a bit.

Customer facing jobs can be awful. I find myself thinking that I could solve a lot of client issues with a shovel, some quicklime, and a watertight alibi. So if you’re on minimum wage in one of the places that treats you like a Victorian mill before the introduction of the Truck Acts, it’s a bit much to expect you to actually give a shit.

It’s perfectly appropriate to blame the owners, but when it comes to staff I’m totally with David Mitchell on this one.

epitome of incomprehensibility

@Surplus – I don’t know about the TV stuff, but for 3), the Air Miles can apply to more than literal air miles. Of course, the amount “earned” per transaction is miniscule, but I suppose whoever came up with that system thought that gamifying things would cause customer addiction…er, loyalty.

And 4) sounds annoying. I’ve had that happen at Tim’s, when someone looks like they’re working at a cash but it’s actually closed.

Also, your “electronics stuff failing” curse seems to have descended on me!*

I bought a new laptop and it kept shutting off unexpectedly. Now it won’t turn on at all. (It’d been marked down from $600 to $400 – maybe that should have been a clue.) Someone I know said I could return it for a refund/exchange if it’s less than a month old. The thing is, I bought Microsoft Office for one machine and I don’t know if I can transfer the license – I don’t see how I can if the machine won’t fucking turn on.

I really should go to the store now and not waste more time on the computer. Stupid ADHD. Machines failing, that’s one thing, but my brain has also been messing with me this week (“oh, let’s stop understanding linear time! let’s make you constantly late for stuff!”)

*not ACTUALLY blaming you, just wanted an excuse to vent. 🙂

Crip Dyke
2 years ago

I could solve a lot of client issues with a shovel, some quicklime, and a watertight alibi

You gotta WARN a gal before you do this kind of thing, Alan. I nearly choked to death laughing, and the international tort case would have been a complete headache, just addressing jurisdictional issues alone!

Surplus to Requirements
Surplus to Requirements
2 years ago

@epitome:

I bought a new laptop and it kept shutting off unexpectedly. Now it won’t turn on at all.

Top 3 things on my suspect list would be “battery issues”, “overheating”, and “bad caps”. Laptops are particularly susceptible to heat and battery issues. Have you tried replacing the battery, if that’s not too expensive or you have a working one with the same size battery to try swapping them as a test?

oh, let’s stop understanding linear time

Have you been exposed to any heptapod logograms recently? Because that’s a known side effect. 🙂

GSS ex-noob
GSS ex-noob
2 years ago

@Alan: Is quicklime really the best option, in today’s world of Better Living Through Chemistry? It doesn’t really work.

http://www.dplylemd.com/criminal-mischief-notes/31-body-disposal.html

Also, your alibi needs to be air-tight, not just water-tight.

Last edited 2 years ago by GSS ex-noob
Raging Bee
Raging Bee
2 years ago

I don’t really think Adams is “taking on ‘woke’ corporations;” it seems to me he’s taking on corporations cleverly/desperately tying themselves in knots PRETENDING to be ‘woke’ without actually changing anything significant. Which is not the funniest he’s ever been, but is mildly amusing — until I hear Adams pretending to be all serious and stuff about being “the voice of ESG opposition,” which isn’t funny at all, just a lot of tiresome self-inflation and pandering to Rash Lamebrain’s audience. News flash: being a CARTOONIST doesn’t make you anyone else’s “voice;” even Bill Watterson (Calvin & Hobbes) and Patrick McDonnell (Mutts) understand that.

Frak all that pretentious nonsense. You can’t be funny when you’re that resentful and take yourself that seriously. If “Dilbert” gets cancelled, it’ll be because it’s not as funny as it used to be. (Oh, and PLEASE cancel “The Family circus” already, I’m totally effing tired of comic strips that make fun of children for being children (who never grow or get older).)

M Haha
M Haha
2 years ago

Liberals don’t decide what cartoons to dump in newspapers. The money guys decide that.