By David Futrelle
What looked last night like farce has turned to tragedy: A speeding car crashed into a crowd of counterprotesters at the so-called #UniteTheRight neo-Nazi march in Charlottesville today, killing one woman and leaving many injured. Video of the incident makes pretty clear that this was an intentional act. The word for this is terrorism.
Details are still scarce, including the identity of the driver, who has apparently been taken into custody. Two police monitoring the protests died in a helicopter crash as well, the cause of which is still unknown.
Here are some tweets that may help to make sense of what has happened and what is happening in Charlottesville. I have put video of the car attack itself behind a content warning at the end of the post.
Pres. Trump says he condemns "egregious display of hatred, bigotry and violence on many sides" in Charlottesville. https://t.co/FQUzBoy9b6 pic.twitter.com/VDANe8Nl8T
— ABC News (@ABC) August 12, 2017
https://twitter.com/GaryLegum/status/896475826618855427
Everyone: Surely you didn't mean to blame people protesting Nazis for Nazi violence?
White House: Oh hell yes we did. pic.twitter.com/7CN1vL15nQ
— Kaili Joy Gray (@KailiJoy) August 12, 2017
The president has been more directly critical of TV hosts, cable news, actresses, comedy shows, & the intelligence community than of nazis.
— Olivia Nuzzi (@Olivianuzzi) August 12, 2017
Trump condemning violence on "Both sides" was foretold when he whitewashed the holocaust into "all people who perished"
— šššš§ šš§š ššššš« š š ā¢ļø (@RemingtonWild) August 12, 2017
6 weeks ago, Trump slashed funding for one of the nation's only groups devoted to combatting neo-Nazi gangs & radical white extremism. pic.twitter.com/Tee5QWbvPB
— Caroline Orr Bueno, Ph.D (@RVAwonk) August 12, 2017
1. TWO DAYS AGO: Top White House adviser says we should stop blaming white supremacists for violence https://t.co/HWZipzcNmv
— Judd Legum (@JuddLegum) August 12, 2017
Video: Alt-right marcher shouting "Heil, Trump" while waving nazi salute
via @tomperriello #charlottesville #AMJoy https://t.co/s3MMSxEhWe
— Scott Dworkin (@funder) August 12, 2017
Scariest image today was not of nazi salutes but of KKK in their new robes – full camo and long guns to appear like the National Guard. pic.twitter.com/IPX3YIZuUv
— Tom Perriello (@tomperriello) August 12, 2017
Unidentified militia has arrived at #EmancipationPark ahead of the #Charlottesville rally with guns in tow. pic.twitter.com/zCLCBU78PF
— Craig Stanley (@_CraigStanley) August 12, 2017
https://twitter.com/MatthewACherry/status/896417584320466944
I was at Ferguson & Baltimore. Trying to imagine police response there if protesters had the artillery the #Charlottesville rioters have.
— Julia Ioffe (@juliaioffe) August 12, 2017
https://twitter.com/jnsanchez/status/896351164756840448
— Yashar Ali š (@yashar) August 12, 2017
And if he doesn't do that then Marco will furrow his brow VERY hard while voting for whatever Trump wants anyway. pic.twitter.com/pfxbOvkWYv
— shauna (@goldengateblond) August 12, 2017
https://twitter.com/jowrotethis/status/896392449760698368
Computer. Give me the stupidest take on #Charlottesville pic.twitter.com/Q4ujbH01uW
— Truther Dare (@truther_dare) August 12, 2017
https://twitter.com/Green_Footballs/status/896488774875533312
The answer to this is to remove every single monument to the rebel traitors on public lands anywhere in the USA. https://t.co/7Hqeu7RnWH
— Richard W. Painter (@RWPUSA) August 12, 2017
CONTENT WARNING: THE VIDEO AND IMAGES OF THE CAR ATTACK AND ITS AFTERMATH BELOW ARE GRAPHIC.
.
.
.
.
https://twitter.com/brennanmgilmore/status/896434516260212737
This disturbing incident was captured by @RyanMKellyPhoto in #Charlottesville today on one of his last days on the job. #photojournalism pic.twitter.com/L2CtTHoVxd
— Bill McKenna (@Wm_McKenna) August 12, 2017
https://twitter.com/ACLUVA/status/896428776988475393
Just checked out Trump’s twitter. Still making mealy mouthed requests for us to all just hold hands and get along!
What a fucking idiot.
@ Coleyote
Porque no los dos?
(Why not both?)
People who call Trump a racist are mistaking him for someone who has beliefs and principles. He would be just as quick to endorse anti-racists if he thought he could get more votes/make more money that way.
I’m trying to follow this story as it develops but it’s getting increasingly terrifying reading how eager these guys (& their online supporters of ””free speech”’) want to kill and hate and blame all their faults on others.
They’re trying to push civil war II while Trump also wants another world war with NK
I’ve run out of tears.
His real estate had a history of racially based housing discrimination. When someone shows you who they are, believe them. I’m not sure why it’s so hard to believe that in addition to being an opportunist, he’s also racist.
Basically, the white nationalists can see the future (Multiracial multicultural Obama is more the future than they are) and it scares the living shit out of them. No more do you automatically get a comfortable life style and lots of respect just for being a white male. (It doesn’t automatically get you a good job at Google either, and that stings.)
Awful. Scary. Awful. I don’t even know what do to or say.
Shoot this filth into space. The lot of em. May the comments policy fall as it may ?
@Grumpy
No, people who’re calling him racist know who he is, know who he’s always been, and believe him when he confirms it. White muffugas really need to stop dismissing/downplaying/excusing racism. From Trump and all his deplorable cesspool. Aggregate patience is running quite thin for such talk…
ETA: ninjad by WWTH
@Axe
Do you really want to run the risk of them being the first representation of our species to someone?
Funny how there was a complete lack of riot police with teargas and truncheons and rubber bullets brutalizing nazis the way they always do BLM…
@Grumpy
Trump is a white supremacist. All Trump voters (yes, all of them, every single last one) are white supremacists. Most white Democrats are also racist as hell. Racist as hell is the default state for US white people, and Republicans (yes, all of them, every last one, including the ones who are your family, friends, and/or coworkers) are not just racist, they are fascist white supremacists. People who act as though they have legitimate points, are expressing legitimate grievances, or ought to be allowed to organize, gather, march, etc. are fascist sympathizers or quislings. Full stop.
Watching the video of the attack was horrific! There is no way that was an accident, the driver literally plowed right into them! And no, Trump, there was no violence ‘on both sides’. It was completely one sided, as it always is when a bigot decides to run into a crowd of innocent, peaceful protestors
Oh my god. My sympathies to the victims, their families, and everyone in the States – and, indeed, out, because we know these arseholes are all connected and cheering one another on online – who is feeling vulnerable, threatened, frightened or marginalised in the wake of this despicable rally and attacks.
I really don’t know what to say other than to express my heartfelt sympathies to the victims and hope they recover quickly. I’m simply not surprised by this though, and unfortunately, this will probably happen again.
This is horrible. Every day brings something more horrible. I’m starting to think about the draft. #45 wants a war. How about the draft for these young white males? Young males, I read years ago, are the most expendable members of a community and, to be crude, have excess testosterone. They’re full of energy and want to fight. So let’s not have a war but prepare for one with the draft. Use up that energy in boot camp, stop beating up people of color and human rights activists.
The philosopher Immanuel Kant said that human beings should be treated as an end in themselves and not as a mere means to an end.
That means no section of the population is “expendable”.
My earlier post about Trump’s racism was intended mostly to be a snarky comment on his lack of any core beliefs beyond his narcissism. I truly believe that he would be a vigorous anti-racist if he thought he could get adulation or votes that way, and he would BELIEVE in that message. Note how his campaign promises on health insurance were basically single payer in everything but name — he was going to repeal Obamacare but provide much better coverage for everyone at a lower price — but now he’s angry that the Senate didn’t pass a bill which was nearly the exact opposite of what he promised.
When I was young nearly everyone was a total homophobe; nobody thought about it much, it was just so. But then more and more gay people came out of the closet, and straight people began to find out that people they liked and respected were gay. The country then flipped on gay marriage and gay rights in an astonishingly swift manner. There are still a lot of people who are deeply committed to homophobic ideas, but they have much less power over gay people’s lives than they used to have.
In particular, the African-American community used to be strongly homophobic because of their religious beliefs, but when it was pointed out to them that discrimination against gays had a lot of similarity to discrimination against them, a lot of minds were changed.
As a straight male, I had some small participation in the gay marriage situation — I testified at a state senate hearing — and my daughter was quite possibly the first person to be gay-married in New Hampshire. So the question occurred to me: as a white person, could I help with racism in a somewhat similar manner. Now I understand that from a person of color’s standpoint, racism is racism, and since all white people have been raised in a racist culture, none of us has been able to avoid having some degree of racism instilled when we were too young to know better. The question is: granted there are some people, like the neo-nazis in Charlottesville, for whom racism is so much a part of their core beliefs that — like the remaining homophobes — there is no real hope of changing most of them. But I happen to believe that there are a lot of whites who could be brought over to the anti-racist side with the proper approach, but unfortunately the Right has been better at reinforcing their racism than liberals have been at combating it.
I had this experience in my own family. When I was in college 50 years ago, I used to have fairly combative arguments with my father over whether or not black people were inferior. I didn’t change his mind, but Martin Luther King did. My father was a person who was willing to change his mind in the face of evidence, and Dr. King proved to him that blacks were not naturally inferior.
One of the problems we have is that respect for diversity speaks in calm, gentle tones, while hatred and bigotry scream at the top of their lungs. I can readily understand how people of color think that racism is so powerful among all whites, because it’s the screaming of the loud proud racists that they mostly hear. I would hope that black people could take some hope from the fact that if you take away the four still Confederate states of South Carolina, Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana, the majority of US white voters chose a black man for the highest position in the country (and would have re-elected him in 2016 if they could). It isn’t everything, but it isn’t nothing either.
So the question for us white people is: is there some way for us to speak to other white people who have at least a semblance of an open mind to try to accomplish the same sort of thing that happened with gay rights. I spend a lot of time on other blogs arguing with people who say that Liberals need to get away from “identity politics” (as if white identity was not identity politics) and multiculturalism, but I’m not sure it has any effect. I mean, does it do any good to argue with someone who claims that the primary purpose of BLM is to murder police? What I do know is that calling people racists when their racism is something they really aren’t conscious of — because they believe right-wing propaganda, and have been convinced that white people are the primary victims of racism — doesn’t work.
If you accept the idea that the vast majority of white people are incurable hard-core racists, then it’s difficult to be optimistic about change.
Sending white supremacists to basic training to learn even better how to use weapons, tactics, strategy, and logistics is not a good idea. It’s possible the Nazi-ness could be indoctrinated out of them, but I seriously doubt our military training process is anywhere near good enough to do that reliably. Nor would I want it to be that good, because it probably would not be used to remove the Nazi-leanings.
Quite a few of the alt-right have been through basic training, and been in the armed forces for a while. I suspect most of them are still Nazis, though they get better at hiding it from non-N’s.
And Cerno’s take… What planet is he from again?
@JS
Neo-nazis have been known to join the armed forces so they can bring that training to the streets.
@Troubelle
Oh, fuck you, moonbeam ?
Fucking hell . So sorry to hear this. And angry too. Love to all affected.
I have to agree with Dali.
Racist as hell is default for white people in America. It was default for me, and I’m pretty sure I’m still racist.
And I do have to agree that anyone who voted for Trump, or for anything he’s tried to push, is explicitly a nazi at worst and a wannabe nazi at best. You simply don’t get a decent human being who looks at Trump and goes “I think he should be allowed to speak.”
If you look at the history in the South during post-war reconstruction… you might be forgiven for thinking the South WON the Civil War.
the US government did an absolutely terrible job of managing the situation after the war ended.
making a new civil war inevitable IMO. I’m surprised it didn’t happen in the 1960s, frankly.
well, if it happens again, just make sure to finish the job this time.
But Immanuel Kant was a real pissant, and very rarely stable.
I cannot believe these people are proudly displaying Nazi symbols in 2017 and getting away with it. In Germany, this would be illegal! How is this a thing? How? I don’t even know what to say.