Earlier today, British politician Jo Cox — a Labour party member of Parliament — was brutally murdered during a meeting with constituents.
While many have been quick to dismiss the horrific attack as the work of a deranged loner, it’s hard not to suspect a political motive: Cox fought against bigotry and was a staunch opponent of Britain leaving the European Union; the man arrested for the crime had connections to a far-right group that defended South Africa’s apartheid government and that has campaigned hard in favor of what’s known as Brexit.
While we still don’t know for sure what the killer’s motives are, that hasn’t stopped some of the most fervent supporters of Brexit are celebrating Cox’s death.
While many of the internet’s most terrible people have been leaning hard on the utterly unsubstantiated notion that the murder was a “false flag” by leftists opposed to #Brexit, others haven’t even bother to pretend that they felt bad about Jo Cox’s violent death.
Naturally, this response hs been most pronounced amongst those on the far right. In the US, that means some of the same people who have been trying their best to whip up anti-Muslim anger in the wake of the Orlando massacre.
It will be no shock to readers of this blog to discover that some of these repugnant alleged humans are also big fans of one Donald J. Trump. Tommy Grooves, a self-described “constitutionalist, Patriot, Libertarian, AltRight, Defender of LIBERTY” actually appended a #Trump2016 hashtag to this horrendous tweet:
https://t.co/YE5R8c2TbX The fate of all the political Traitor all over the world in every country.There day of reckoning ! #Trump2016
— Tommy Grooves (@Tommygrooves) June 16, 2016
In the tweet immediately preceding that one, for what it’s worth, he suggested that a writer for Vox needed to be taken on a “TRUMP HELICOPTER RIDE,” presumably a reference to Chilean dictator’s Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet’s practice of murdering people by throwing them from helicopters into the ocean. (See CORRECTION note below.)
#WhiteResistance, a frequent sharer of Trump’s tweets, as well as those of right-wing internet celebrities like Lauren Southern and Vox Day, had a similar reaction:
(These tweets were removed while I was writing this post, hence the screenshots.)
And there were many others — not all of them Trump fans, but most of them from the far right.
https://twitter.com/NANorthEast_/status/743473897828409344
https://twitter.com/NANorthEast_/status/743497714353246209
https://twitter.com/Fckislam10/status/743528636771270657
https://twitter.com/Fckislam10/status/743531853265543168
https://twitter.com/Steve_Crawford1/status/743543766020042753
https://twitter.com/KerrierKernow/status/743457087917854720
https://twitter.com/BodoKnerz/status/743515167732940800
https://twitter.com/Brassidi/status/743505912401432576
https://twitter.com/franz_soapbar/status/743497007881400320
Over on the rabidly pro-Trump internet Nazi tabloid The Daily Stormer, editor Andrew Anglin and most of his followers seem to be leaning towards the “false flag” theory. Other commenters had a rather different take:
While some celebrated today’s murder, one fellow predicted future murders — some of them possibly carried out by him.
Yet more reminders of how ugly politics have gotten in this misbegotten Year of Trump.
EDIT: Added link to Daily Stormer discussion (archived) and additional comment from there.
CORRECTION: An earlier version of this post suggested that the reference to “Trump helicopter rides” was an allusion to a famous scene in Scarface in which a man is murdered by throwing him from a helicopter; it’s far more likely that it was a reference to Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet’s practice of murdering people by throwing them from helicopters into the ocean.
*** If you can vote, but don’t.
@ guest
It’s completely understandable to be upset by this horrible murder. But part of the reason it’s so shocking is precisely because such events are so rare and unexpected. Perhaps you can take some comfort for the fact that the almost universal response to this callous killing has been condemnation of the perpetrator and expressions of sympathy and tributes to his victim.
As for the malicious wankers quoted in the original post, their hatred is matched only by their stupidity. It’s true immigration is an issue in the EU debate (a major one but not the only one) but the concerns are about white immigration. Ironically they’d find more fellow travellers within the European Parliament, which contains a worryingly large number of unapologetic fascist parties.
ETA: not suggesting anyone here in the remain camp falls into that category of course, the EU is a complex issue and there’s plenty of arguments for staying in.
@ IP
That sounds interesting. Since going veggie I’ve being using a lot of fungi to get that umami taste.
Lovage is really popular here in the West Country. The story goes that it was invented to add to smuggled brandy to disguise the salty taste where sea water had seeped into the barrels during the smuggling operations. Don’t know if that’s true but do like brandy and lovage (hmm, maybe I should try adding some seawater, might be even better)
@Alan Jo Cox’s murder is horrible, but what’s really upsetting me is the ugliness stirred up by the Leavers. I’m also disturbed by the fact that (although I haven’t exercised it much) I can currently work anywhere in the EU if I choose to–if we leave, that will no longer be true. And, as I’ve explained to a few people, I think membership in the EU is the only thing supporting the rights we currently have as workers, consumers and citizens. I’ve seen some brochures saying things like ‘we could spend all the money we’re giving to the EU on the NHS if we leave’…how likely is that? In addition to the economic disruption caused by leaving, our living standards will plummet once businesspeople and conservative government are no longer constrained by broader regulations. So…did I make the right decision? I’d be feeling a lot safer somewhere else in Europe right now.
@IP Too bad I don’t like mushrooms 🙁
@blueberrypancake from the previous page:
Frankly YES. Where have you been for the last 40 years? Trump has a long, long history of saying and doing racist things. His father was a KKK supporter and had a history of discriminating against black tenants (as noted by Woody Guthrie). Trump carried on the tradition, ordering his supervisors to mark black applicants’ paperwork with a ‘C’ and lie to them about the availability of housing. In 1973, the Justice Department sued Trump’s company for “refusing to rent or negotiate rentals because of race or color”. He settled in 1975, but just three years later, was under fire again for discriminatory rental practices.
According to one former Trump employee, whenever Donald visited one of his casinos, black employees were ordered off the floor. He was quoted as saying “Black guys counting my money! I hate it. The only kind of people I want counting my money are short guys that wear yarmulkes every day”, and he himself affirmed that that quote was “probably true”. He also had black and female employees removed at the request of Robert Libutti, a high roller with alleged connections to the mob. Libutti hated gambling in their presence. Trump denied any knowledge of Libutti, but his daughter told an interviewer that her father and Trump frequently socialized together, flew in his helicopter, went on his yacht, and Trump attended her 35th birthday at the Plaza.
When Trump was fighting against a proposed Native American casino in New York, which would have competed against his Atlantic City casino, Trump took out anomymous newspaper ads featuring drug paraphenelia, which read “Are these the new neighbors we want?” and accusing the Mohawk community of “criminal activity”. He also spent $85,000 on full page ads in four different newspapers after the Central Park jogger rape, calling for the death penalty and stoking the flames of racial tension in the city.
That’s just the TIP of the iceberg. There are many, many, many other examples of Trump’s despicable behavior, stretching back 4 decades.
But hey, as you yourself said, never let the facts get in the way of a good
rambling right-wing conspiracy saladstory.@guest
But are you vegetarian? The main course for meat eaters was the same thing but with lamb instead of the mushroom.
Blueberrypacakeswmaplesyrup
There is a film of an interview with a witness where he said he heard Britian First or Put Britian First being shouted. It may be that he was not really a witness, but it looks like it is not “The Left” that is saying this. If you read the article it is TRUMP supporters who are themselves celebrating what happened, not David Furtrelle who is saying this in his post.
Nothing the far right says suprises me anymore. If these scumbags existed in the 1860s they’d be calling John Wilks Booth a “patriot”
One major difference between #WhiteGenocide and all other genocides, is that #WhiteGenocide contains no genocide.
This is why over the top, violent rhetoric is so dangerous. When people actually believe that there’s a genocide being committed against their own group, they can justify the murder of perceived enemies. It’s the same problem as with Christians who target abortion clinics. If you genuinely believe that thousands of human babies are being murdered in that clinic, taking out the perceived executioner is not irrational. I truly wish there were some way to hold conservative politicians and pundits responsible for these attacks. I view them as accomplices in a very real sense.
Quoted for truth.
‘One major difference between #WhiteGenocide and all other genocides, is that #WhiteGenocide contains no genocide.’
Well said. I do eat meat, so could have the lamb…. An old college friend of mine lives with her family in Gothenburg. I visited her there like 15 years ago; she visited me in the UK maybe 8? years ago, but we don’t keep in touch. I should write her anyway, and see if she’s up for a visit sometime.
People are dying in the east to join the European Union and people are dying in the west to remain in it.
BTW, outside of the typical “hatred because of difference”, is there any reflexion on why exactly veganism cause so much hatred ? Is that because of a vocal minority ?
I know for one that in addition to some reasonable complaint (like, why have empathy for ducks but not mushrooms), I also have some irrational anger toward vegans. I guess it hit some part of the unconscious I am not aware of.
@ guest
I can understand your concerns. I’m marginally in favour of leave (but not especially passionate about it, might not even vote, that’s not apathy, just leaving it to people who do have strong feelings and go along with the democratic choice)
If we do Brexit my preferred option would be to join EFTA. I’d also keep all the free movement provisions (although I can understand people wanting the ability to deport serious sexual and violent offenders). I’m actually in favour of free movement within the Commonwealth too.
Under that option nothing much would change. TAFTA is going to subsume all the EU regs on trade, and we can be part of that as easily under EFTA as through the EU and TTIP. Most of the things people are concerned about in terms of workers’s rights are actually more beneficial under UK law the a the EU requirements anyway (stuff like maternity leave, maternity pay, paid holidays etc.). EU environmental and consumer law is directly copied from UK law so that’s not an issue either.
Ironically I think the old Bennite left wing case for Brexit is actually stronger than the right wing one. The EU is specially set up to promote capitalism and free trade as a priority so I can see why a lot of old school socialists aren’t too keen on that. It is true that EU immigrants add about £20 billion to the UK economy, but not a lot of that trickles down and the bottom 10% of society are supposedly worse off.
To give you an example from my own experience, I do a lot of work for a series of companies involved in construction (in reality one entity with lots of linked companies I set up). They use east European labour, import materials from Scandinavia and pay tax in whatever country offers the best deal at the time. That’s great for their workers. They’re young lads who work 70-80 hour weeks. It’s not just the cliche they work harder (although that’s true) but they’re much higher skilled than the indigenous labour force. They work here for a few years and save the cash, then they go home and set up businesses their with their capital. Whilst they are here they live pretty cheaply. A landlord of a family size house can stick 2 beds in each bedroom and 2 in the living room and charge £60 a week. The guys love that, they’re hardly there so they just need a place to crash. The landlord is getting nearly £1500 a month so he’s happy; but how many families can afford that?
Immigration is a major issue in the EU debate, but I think for most people it’s about economics rather than race.
Tl;dr. under the most likely Brexit scenarios your position would remain unchanged.
Not to be weird, but maybe a post on the brutal murder of a woman and the terrifying reactions it has elicited isn’t the best place for a discussion on the finer points of veganism?
Just feels really disrespectful to me. :/
@ALW
Are you new here? Threads always derail after a while. When we want to talk about something off topic, we usually post in the most recent/active thread. Almost every thread is about something terrible. Not talking about veganism won’t bring the victim back to life.
IP wanted to share something they were excited about, and I appreciated that they did it.
@Ohlmann, funny that you should mention that. I’ve been wondering about this myself recently. I’ve been vegetarian for a long time, and have seriously considered veganism a few times (there are in fact quite reasonable arguments that if you care enough to be vegetarian, why not be vegan?).
Lately I’ve noticed more and more ‘aggro’ towards vegans from my students. I teach at two different universities, across several faculties, and covering very different demographics (the joys of being a casual academic). Anyway, I started asking them about it, and they in return showed me some of the stuff that *some* vegans apparently think, that happens to be the most visible on social media. Which is that the rest of us are evil and stupid. And vegetarians are even worse than omnivores (sorry, “carnies”, which is problematic because it already has a history quite unrelated to diet).
The type of veganism that people are reacting against seems, to me, to be judgemental and unhelpful. Please note that I’m absolutely not extending these comments to vegans in general.
Not sure if this resonates with your experience 🙂
I’m still half asleep, but what I’m getting from pancake troll’s screeds is that criticizing people for celebrating the murder of Jo Cox makes us equivalent to Pol Pot, Stalin, and Mao. At least they didn’t compare us to Hitler!
Isn’t it now confirmed that the shooter was in a neo-Nazi group? So, troll is wrong.
BTW, troll. It’s kind of pathetic to dare us to bring the vitriol when you’re just a drive by thread shitter.
@ ohlmann & mish
A significant number of my closest friends are vegans, including the person I care most about in the world (she got promoted when my dog passed away). They can be a bit didactic. And never mind the controversy over the ‘Protein World’ advert, I’ve been bombarded with Renee Somerfield clogging up my Facebook feed for years!
I love my friends dearly, but I do post this clip in response a lot. Luckily they can laugh at themselves and accept there’s quite a bit of truth in it.
https://youtu.be/SFCAcQxmYDI
Ohlman,
Part of it is the stereotype of the militant vegan, I suppose. None of the vegans I’ve known are like that though. I find the paleo diet fans much more pushy and militant.
Part of it is that some people get weirdly offended by people liking and disliking different foods. See the New York vs. Chicago pizza wars.
I’m just gonna say I strongly suspect that anti-vegan and anti-vegetarian attitudes are often linked to toxic masculinity.
@Ohlmann
Probably the tendency for them to be rude and pushy, and racist, ableist, and classcist.
I’ve seen some pretty nasty and ignorant things out of vegans. And that doesn’t mean all of them are bad, but they’re not very good about collecting their trash. If it were just vegans going around calling people silly names like “bloodmouth” I could probably shrug it off, but I’ve seen them get very combative with poor people who can’t afford vegan diets, and all manner of disabled people who have a wide variety of reasons vegan diets just can’t work for them.
There’s also with some of them a tendency to trend foods like quinoa, and they’ll going around acting morally superior about their vegan diets, while ignoring how much damage the quinoa trend is doing to actual human beings.
Then there’s the ones who compare cows to rape victims and livestock in general to slaves.
My own first experience with a vegan was my high school CP English teacher. She would lecture our class about how vegan foods like tofu are superior and way more healthy, and in general carrying on like she was better than other people for having a healthier lifestyle. I mostly ignored this, until the day I discovered she was a chain smoker. (She also went off on this bizarre tangent one time, about how anal sex loosens your anal muscles and you’ll end up in diapers, so don’t do that.)
I can’t say anyone who’s encountered this sort of behavior has an irrational hatred of vegans. Personally, as an autistic person with major issues with food textures, I tend to twitch whenever I see them. I can’t change or control the fact that a lot of the foods they champion have a texture that makes my tongue try to curl up in the fetal position. Being chastised and called names for something like that is going to be off-putting to most people, I think.
@guest I live in Scotland and to be honest, in the event we leave the EU, I for one will regret voting to stay in the UK and would advocate another shot at the Indyref