And we return once again to the Red Pill subreddit, where the locals are finding intellectual inspiration in the manifesto of one slightly problematic Norwegian, er, thinker — Anders Breivik, a far-right, antifeminist ideologue who decided to promote this manifesto by murdering 77 people with guns and a bomb.
Dudes, when you find yourself saying “Lisa Simpson needs to be punched in the face, but this neo-Nazi mass murderer makes some good points” it might be time for you to sit down and clear your head and rethink your entire fucking life.
H/T — r/TheBluePill, for the second time today.
Cultural Marxism, as far as I can tell, means “sometimes beings that are not cis het white able-bodied neurotypical dudes get treated like actual people! The horror!”
The above quotes by the way are from the leader of one of America’s last standing and much beloved peace and love spiritual hippie organizations.
“Oh, and if these people start bringing up The Frankfurt School, well, it’s not because they’re interested in discussing the theories of actual cultural Marxists like Theodor Adorno or Herbert Marcuse.”
OK so did Adorno and Marcuse or anyone on staff at The Frankfurt chool actually refer to themselves as “cultural marxists”?
Didn’t the Frankfurt School become the New School for Social Research and later just The New School? Does anyone there call themselves a “cultural marxist”?
Is “Cultural Marxist Theory” a course anywhere? Who coined this term?
No, nobody calls themselves a “cultural marxist.” It was coined by the right-wingers as a thought-stopper.
It isn’t a course anywhere. It’s a Gingrich-style neologism used to denounce anything and everything they don’t like, from marriage equality to Common Core, because apparently shouting “COMMIES! COMMIES! COMMIES!” doesn’t work anymore.
It just means “Not a neo-Nazi” with a subtext of “TEH JOOOZ.” Which isn’t an exaggeration, since it’s only used by people who are neo-Nazis.
Many MRAs, red pillers, gamergaters, etc think feminists, gay rights activists and other “SJWs” are being manipulated by this evil Jewish cabal. Because we can’t think for ourselves and I suppose anyone who isn’t a cishet white man wouldn’t really want rights and to be regarded as human beings if we weren’t having our strings pulled. Because reasons.
The first time I heard the term “Cultural Marxism” was in the context of a completely ridiculous conspiracy theory about how Theodor Adorno wrote all the Beatles’ lyrics in order to facilitate the downfall of traditional American values and morals via the British invasion, or something (and also Paul is dead). So seeing people start talking about it as some kind of legitimate political theory – not to mention commiting mass murder in its name – still feels really, really weird.
So to avoid the disgusting thrust of the comments in the OP apparently my brain has decided to focus in on just one detail to be confused about… are they saying that barbarians were so, um, civilized (!?) that they only invaded cities when the gate was open? Did they sometimes get through the defenders just to come to a closed gate and say “well shucks guys, better pack it in and go home, the gate’s shut!” (and now I’m imagining a conversation about whether anyone had tried the door to see if it were locked… but I’m not funny enough to write it out, so imagine at will!)
I thought the whole “barbarians at the gate” thing was meant to indicate that the army defending the city had fallen and the barbarians had made it to the gates of the city, so now was the time for civilians to flee in the opposite direction if at all possible…?
“Didn’t the Frankfurt School become the New School for Social Research and later just The New School?”
They’re using “school” to mean “body of literature / set of theories” in the same way that the Chicago School is a macroeconomic theory and not a school in Chicago. Many of the writers who created the Frankfurt School came to the US and continued writing there. Nobody call themselves a “cultural Marxist,” but there’s a kernel of truth to the idea: it’s basically a conspiracy theorist/russophobe/anti-semite’s misunderstanding of solidarity and intersection.
If you think of “patriarchy” as not only “the domination of women by men,” but “a society structured by hierarchy and chains of domination, in which are subject to men but most men are in turn subject to the whims of a small class of wealthy and privileged old men.” (Obviously, plenty of left-radicals were and are sexist) Plus, Marx himself was not feminist icon, but he did understand that real economic liberation would radically alter the way people married and formed families. Feminism, Anti-Racism, and LGBT Liberation are also anti-patriarchy movements. Some extremely unsophisicated patriarchs can’t be bothered to distinguish between people who are against them and other people who are against them and think of all social justice movements as an undifferentiated blob. You know, “SJWs.”
Slightly more sophisticated ones noticed that although these are different movements, there was a lot of overlap. Sure, feminism has race problems and the gay movement has gender problems and black churches has lgbt problems and so on, but on the whole, people who favor justice tend to favor justice, and in the same way that bigotry movements cross-pollinate, so do justice movements.
Conspiracy theorists see that overlap and assume that someone has to be “behind it”, orchestrating the whole thing, so they blame the people they always blame: Jews, Communists, and Jewish Communists. So “Cultural Marxism” is the idea that because some feminists are Jewish and some are Communists, Feminism must be controlled be and created by The Jews.
Also, “Marxist-Feminism” is a real thing, so that adds to the confusion. Basically Marxist-Feminists run with the idea that “history is a history of class struggle,” but go on to say that we should pay attention to the conflict between “men” and “women” as well as the conflict between “labor” and “capital”
OMG, what a bunch of idiots full of sound and fury signifying nothing. Even in Germany, where all able-bodied males between 18 and 21 are required to do military service (or civilian service if they conscientiously object), conscription is NOT a precondition for the vote. Everyone is able to vote at 18, even if found unfit for military service…or female, in which case military service is optional.
And really: if Anders Breivik is “relevant” to your interests, you’re not the pro-freedom party, fellas. You’re the fucking fascists.
“The first time I heard the term “Cultural Marxism” was in the context of a completely ridiculous conspiracy theory about how Theodor Adorno wrote all the Beatles’ lyrics in order to facilitate the downfall of traditional American values and morals via the British invasion, or something (and also Paul is dead). So seeing people start talking about it as some kind of legitimate political theory – not to mention commiting mass murder in its name – still feels really, really weird.”
The Oregon shooting? I wonder if he was an MRA or Manospherian?
They think an incel did it;
https://kiwifar.ms/threads/incel-loser-goes-shooting-in-oregon.13034/
And isn’t there also some theory that the Beatles lyrics were Vatican propaganda? LOL.
Thanks Orion for the explanation. I do recall reading though that the Frankfurt School of thought had some connection with the New School for Social Research in Manhattan.
Falconer, what do they have against Common Core?
Ahhh yes, here it is!
Thomas Hobbes
“Zounds! Roosk is an irrelevance and ROK writers are all heretics who must needs bow down and pray worshipfuly to our almighty Lord. Why is he hiding the truth about the John Lennon assassination? The powers that be silenced him because the Beatles were about to reunite to record a Gregorian chant album. Ye my comrades, though art wise to abandon and condemn the neomasculinity apocrypha; rather be ye authentic prayer warriors to God, the sun, and the Holy Paraclete; also is it not suspicious that Beethoven became deaf just as he was building new horizons in music; is that not what Rosh should be writing about? Please consider.”
“Paul McCartney predicted the new beautiful direction of Russian orthodoxy in Back in the USSR; Vladimir Putin secretly visited England as a teenager and helped write the song and others for The Beatles. Shakespeare also made a secret visit to Russia in the year 1600 where he met with a good sage who inspired him to write plays against feminism; however, the Royal Secret Police endeavored most voraciously to stop him. Christopher Marlowe was involved in this but he was assassinated before he could reveal it.”
Charles Manson was originally a spy for the Vatican but then turned on them. Thomas Aquinas wrote coded language in the Summa Theologicum which predicteth and established with forebearance and much patience that there would be a great idolator against the Church.”