Do you remember when #GamerGate was young? You know, back before #NotYourShield and Vivian James and bizarrely complicated conspiracy theories involving Gawker, Weird Twitter and some sort of international Jewish conspiracy?
Remember when #GamerGate was still called #BurgersAndFries, and the angry gamebro army was focused on the real enemy of all that is good and true – a young game designer by the name of Zoe Quinn?
If you’ve been feeling nostalgic for those good old days, you’re in luck. A sprawling blog post by a female friend of Quinn’s obsessive, accusatory ex-boyfriend Eron Gjoni takes us back to the dog days of August when his even more sprawling thezoepost was unleashed upon the world.
Rachel M, who describes herself as an “engineer, designer, accidental writer,” recalls the months she spent with Gjoni as he began to process his breakup with Quinn and marshal his arguments against her. She was there when he posted thezoepost, making her a sort of midwife of what became #GamerGate.
It’s no secret whose side of this controversy she’s on. Her depictions of Gjoni are written with affection and indulgence; her portrayal of Quinn is brutal and a step or two beyond unfair. When Rachel M pretends for a moment that she’s not “someone with an ax to grind against Zoe,” that’s because her little hatchet is already buried in Quinn’s back.
If there is a point to GamerGate Launched in My Apartment, and, Internet, I’m Sorry (Not that sorry) beyond making Gjoni look angelic and Quinn look like a demon, I’m not sure what it is.
After presenting us with a series of uninteresting and unnecessary details of her own life, Rachel M repeats a number of largely discredited myths about Quinn and even seems to have made up a new myth of her own, accusing Quinn of “telling Eron she believed I was lying about my PTSD” in an online chat.
Never mind that the chat log itself, which Gjoni pasted into his zoepost, and which Rachel M also pasted into an earlier post of her own, suggests that Quinn was dubious not about Rachel M’s medical diagnoses but about Rachel’s intentions towards her then-boyfriend.
As I searched through the screenshots on Eron’s site to see if Rachel M’s recollections of this exchange matched the evidence, I was struck again by the utter surreality of #BurgersAndFries and its successor #GamerGate.
Because, the thing is, I don’t want to be reading these chat logs. I shouldn’t be reading these chat logs. These are private moments between two people at a vulnerable moment in both of their lives. They shouldn’t have been posted on the internet in an act of petty revenge against an ex-girlfriend. They shouldnt’ be on the internet at all.
The fact that the details of Zoe Quinn and Eron Gjoni’s sex lives and their messy breakup are so central to the conflicts now roiling the video game world that I have to turn to these screenshots to fact check this post is weird and wrong and rather depressing. Zoe Quinn isn’t the president, caught pantsless in flagrante delicto with a Haliburton lobbyist. She’s a video game developer, and the details of her sexual history are none of our fucking business.
None of this matters much to Rachel M, who seems to have become trapped in Gjoni’s reality distortion field, borrowing some of his narcissism for herself. She describes Gjoni’s decision to “go public” with the ugly details of his breakup with Quinn and her various alleged infidelities and lies:
Eron talked about going public. He talked about panic, about awareness, about making sure that people knew what they were getting into, about taking a hit – there’d be a hit, for speaking publicly against a woman in any field, but especially against a woman with Zoe’s position and friends in progressive indie gaming – for the good of all, eventually.
This is so perverse and backwards and wrong it’s hard not to wonder if Gj himself wrote it.
He talked about evaluating the risk to his current job, his future jobs, his family, himself. You know, whether he’d get stalked or murdered for this. He talked about the danger to Zoe, about how he could minimize personal harm toward her, whether he could effectively defray harassment towards her.
Well, he did a bangup job of that, huh?
He settled on a few plans toward that end, and decided the risk to himself was worth it. Even the total loss cases for him still meant greater than zero public knowledge about Zoe’s manipulative behavior, her role as an abuser, and the number of lies she’d told. Anything was better than the way it was now.
Really? Because for a lot of people, not just Quinn, things have gotten a lot worse since Gjoni launched his attack against his ex.
Rachel M is actually quite aware of this; indeed, she notes explicitly that the movement that was born out of Gjoni’s long post has directed much of its fury towards women.
Zoe received floods of hate and threats within hours of the post going live. Anita Sarkeesian, a feminist media critic, was forced to cancel a speech at USU after receiving death threats referencing the École Polytechnique Massacre … Brianna Wu, Liana K, and anyone who identifies as a feminist within gaming — they’ve been getting smeared.
Women in games, creators and critics alike, are working through a tide of hate that’s reached the front page of the New York Times. Each new story makes me a little sicker.
Yet somehow she’s still “not that sorry” she helped Gjoni to launch the movement that caused all this. She thinks it’s all somehow … good for women. Because people now know what she thinks is the truth about Zoe Quinn. She ends her post with these bizarre assertions:
I want more women in tech and media, at all levels—in development, in journalism, in the games and books and comics themselves.
I want those women to be as safe, respected, creative, and supported as any man, and I do not want them unprepared in an industry with Zoe Quinn.
And this, I guess, is how someone who helped Gjoni to usher in a hateful, spiteful, reactionary “movement” that has left numerous women fearing for their lives convinces herself that she’s on the side of the angels after all.
EDIT: I corrected Rachel M’s name. No idea why my brain turned her name into Sarah.
@weirwoodtreehugger: I dunno, the area where I grew up Sara was the more common spelling but that would still happen to the Saras I knew. I really do blame the Bible because what else would it even be
Fuck. I have to take a break and come back later. The clueless assholes who keep making excuses for Gjoni’s personal hate campaign — and helping him with it, are making me ill. Do you idiots know what a witch trial is? Do you?
The whole thing (not gamer gate, the ex stuff) is so disgustingly petty. “I want women in gaming [but] I do not want them unprepared in an industry with Zoe Quinn” This one woman. who has made one or two small games. who sits outside of main stream like Warren Zevon where people say “wow, cool” but few really take into their record collections. One single woman who once had sex with this dude. (or even one single woman who sold herself for a brilliant review – not that it ever happened) is worth this entire thing. cause Zoe Quinn, you know.
the whole damn thing comes off as teh “best girl friend who is always there cause she wishes she were the actual girlfriend” grudge we had at 13, when some “bitch” dumped “our guy”.
I know that here on WHTM we don’t need any reminder of the mess that is 4chan but I just read something that brings it all to a new level of horrible. Someone posted a picture of a dead woman, apparently strangled, on 4chan giving the town watch the news and saying she would be found soon. She was found an hour later. No details. I am stunned.
If anyone finds that conversation, I’d be interested to see how 4chan reacted.
Unfuckingbelievable.
Yeah, I saw that too, zennurse. It’s so fucked up.
Tanya, the ex stuff is gamergate. A misogynist asked for help to harass his ex, and he got it. What, you actually thought this was about ethics in game journalism? When someone actually gives out critical analysis of games, they threaten that person with rape and murder. Do the math.
Zennurse and Shiraz: That is beyond horrible. There are simply no words for that.
@zennurse
… Again? Jesus Christ. How many fucking times is this going to happen before that cesspit gets shut down?
Ho.ly.shit.
I am aghast.
Wow. Who would have thought that a forum that encourages bad talk might attract people who do bad acts?
That is beyond horrible.
But it’s actually about ethics in game journalism, honest!
Bah. Embedded image fail. What I WANTED to do was embed this:
http://i.imgur.com/nhRYQdx.jpg
I read the piece when Medium highlighted it a couple of days ago, and I was hoping WHTM would tackle it because I honestly wasn’t sure if I was reading it right. Can anyone really be so monstrously self-absorbed? (And if I was trying to convince people of Eron’s sense of emotional proportionality, I’m not sure I would have included the cat anecdote.)
Since I read it I notice she added a note to the head about how she wishes everyone safety, blah blah blah. Does she really still not understand that SHE’s the one who put people in danger?
A couple days ago I was also introduced to the concept of the “black swan event” via Glen Beck. It’s a term he’s started using as synonymous with “false flag operation,” but I guess he feels it’s not tarred with the tinfoil hat conspiracy implications of that term. And though the guy who invented the idea seems like kind of a jerk, it does apply to “GamerGate Launched in My Apartment.”
So the general idea of the black swan event is that it’s an unusual event, even vanishingly unlikely, yet still a predictable consequence of a certain set of factors. I’m not sure if Rachel M is being completely truthful when she says she just wanted to warn people about the terrible scourge on the industry Zoe Quinn was, but she had to know that there was a chance the blog post was going to have professional implications for Quinn, and that there was a chance it would become an internet shit-storm, because that’s what happens when you post things to 4chan. (The fact that in her version of the narrative 4chan “found” the blog post, as if it was divine intervention, is all the proof I need that she’s not being completely honest.)
Maybe we need to make this whole situation a bit more relatable. Let’s imagine that Eron and Rachael, rather than posting tell-all blog posts, decided to the burn pictures of Zoe Quinn in effigy. And while they were doing that an ember fell under a desk, and before they noticed it, it kindled a fire. This fire is too big for them to put out themselves, so the fire department is called and all the other apartments in the building are evacuated. Under those circumstances would Rachel try to defend her actions to the other tenants by saying, “I know I’ve inconvenienced everyone and put you all in danger, but don’t all of you understand that Zoe Quinn once said something a little thoughtless about me in an internet chat? I HAD to burn those pictures!” I can’t imagine that would fly, but that seems to be Rachel M’s attitude.
…that Vader meme.
I can’t. It’s too much funny. I, I, I just can’t.
Well, actually, she didn’t put Zoe in danger — Gjoni did. Rachel obviously has Stockholm syndrome.
@Scott:
I heard about Black Swan events through a completely different source, where it seems to have a very different meaning. Basically it’s an event that’s large, impactful, and objectively unpredictable, yet human nature causes people in hindsight declare it could have been predicted with information that wouldn’t have actually been enough to predict anything.
I’m not sure what the theory is supposed to explain, since it seems to boil down to “much of human history is dictated by unpredictable events,” but whatevs.
Totally read that Vader meme in James Earl Jones’s voice. It was pretty epic.
I don’t think we should be diagnosing people with syndromes when we don’t know them. And yes, I know she didn’t write the blog post, but in her telling of the story she was instrumental in encouraging Eron to post it, so she shares the blame.
People like Eron and Sarah make me sick. How they could ever think they are the “good guys” in all of this amazes me. If I knew people like this IRL I would cut them out so fast their heads would spin.
So are we saying that Glen Beck took a phrase that already had an established meaning and redefined it to suit his own purposes? Is that what I’m understanding?
Scott, I wasn’t actually diagnosing anyone. I don’t do that. But I am familiar with the old, “A man behaved badly?! If there’s a woman nearby, let’s blame her!” Bullshit.
@Shiraz:
You just wrote that. There are other ways to call out the “if there’s a woman nearby, let’s blamer her” mentality if you think people are doing that here than to insinuate some mental condition on the woman.
@Shiraz
I’m pretty sure I was pretty clear that I wasn’t letting Eron off the hook, as I mentioned him as many times as Rachel M. It is completely possible for more than one person to be responsible for shitty behavior, and sometimes one of those people will be a woman. I’m not sure how not wanting to blame women for things they didn’t do relates to Stockholm Syndrome, but it doesn’t matter, in this particular case Rachel M is pretty clear that she went out of her way to encourage Eron to post the blog. She really did do it.
@Policy of Madness:
I know right? What a twist! If Scott was accurately describing Glen’s definition, though, then the irony levels will break every meter within three solar systems, since Glen’d be precisely exemplifying how Black Swan events are ones that people will swear were predictable when they really couldn’t have been.