Categories
a voice for men antifeminism creepy FemRAs men who should not ever be with women ever misogyny MRA patriarchy patronizing as heck

A Voice for Men’s DriverSuz: “Male care and compassion for women is why women don’t live in barns and pens with the cows, pigs and chickens.”

So I’ve been skimming through the mass of comments that the Daily Beast piece on the Men’s Rightsers now has trailing in its wake. So far I think this is my favorite exchange.

AngryHarry 10 hours ago  If the men throughout history had not been concerned about their women, they would have bred them like cattle, (Who could have stopped them?)  But every single ancestor - stretching back to time immemorial - of every feminist on this forum was protected from death by, mostly, men.    Every single one of them.  We are lucky to exist at all.  Worth thinking about. FlagShare 3LikeReply driversuz 9 hours ago  @AngryHarry   Absolutely correct. Male care and compassion for women is why women don't live in barns ans pens with the cows, pigs and chickens. No external entity prevented men from forcing us to live like farm animals and from socializing us to be relatively comfortable with it.

Yep, that’s DriverSuz — aka Suzanne McCarley, “Senior Editor” of A Voice for Men.

And yep, that’s Angry Harry, the fellow that many MRAs call “the father of the men’s rights movement.”

Some critics of this blog complain whenever I quote some crackpot commenter rather than one of the “big names” in the Men’s Rights movement. Sometimes, it turns out, the crackpot commenters ARE the “big names” in the Men’s Rights movement.

336 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
SittieKitty
11 years ago

I have an intense hatred of the c-word. And I’m not keen on bitch even as a reclamation simply because of the etymology of it…

Oh, and fuck no, cannot deal with themask&therose tonight, I’m so beyond being able to deal with shit. They’re a miserable putrescent pile of pus that needs to live in a lego house filled with water just higher than their nose so they have to walk around awkwardly all the time and cannot lie down without drowning. And tonight I can’t even fucking care enough to get angry about them…

kittehserf
11 years ago

SittieKitty – don’t worry, David banned themaskandrose.

SittieKitty
11 years ago

I caught up on the other thread and saw that kitteh, thanks 🙂 I was certain they’d been banned before as well but I could be wrong and can’t be arsed to go look it up and really don’t care.

kittehserf
11 years ago

Yeah, I was pretty sure he was on permamod or banhammer from his shit last time – I was too lazy to look it up, too, so just emailed David. All hail the Dark Lord!

SittieKitty
11 years ago

In-fucking-deed.

melody
11 years ago

If any group talked about, say, minorities the way the MRAs routinely talk about women, it would be viewed as unconscionable hate speech. The MRA is the sexist equivalent of the KKK.

Yep. Not that many MRMs have not posted racists AND sexist BS as well. Fetishization of asian and black women is not uncommon in the MRA crew.

melody
11 years ago

Wait is mask and rose the troll who made those comments about rape victims?

Dvärghundspossen
11 years ago

Okay, “fitted” – just expanded my English vocabulary! And regarding girls’ and boys’ lego not combining, maybe my colleague just meant that the lego people look all differently, or that they’re completely different colour schemes or something, rather than they being physically impossible to combine.

Anyway, it’s messed up that things are moving backwards when it comes to kids and gender.

kittehserf
11 years ago

melody – I don’t remember the specifics, but it was definitely something about rape that got themaskandrose banned/modded the first time round.

kittehserf
11 years ago

::rolls eyes:: Don’t they all?

mildlymagnificent
11 years ago

We were kids playing in dirt. Sheesh, even my dresses were more brown and orange hued, but that could’ve just been a late seventies/early eighties thing.

Yup. My girls were born 81 and 84. I even had toddler-sized brown. corduroy. overalls, for the older one. As for toys. They were just toys. mr hated Barbie dolls with an all-consuming passion. Not in my house!! He eventually relented when the younger one really, really wanted one for Xmas when she was sevenish. But they had huge buckets of prime colours lego, yellow Tonka trucks and all kinds of mechanical toys and games as well as the super expensive Meccano kits. (And train sets. I’ve now been informed that they weren’t much fun. I was guilty of organising/ playing with them too much and I got in their way.)

Pinkification started with Barbie from my point of view. Apart from trikes and bikes. Girls and boys bikes were basically the same but distinguished by a different colour and accessory selection. Much wider selection than just pink/purple versus black/yellow/red then. But there was no need for it to go the way it has.

As for clothes. I have a piccie somewhere of my soldier/ outback stockman/ uber-conventional dad when he was probably two years old. In a dress! With smocking on it! Ankle-length! When babies were babies, children were children, adults were adults and there were defined steps along the way. I think my kids generation was the last where you could still dress babies in white and just add a ribbon or other sex identifying accessory.

As for dressing alike. I dressed them in exactly the same clothes a lot of the time. If I hadn’t, no one would have known they were together, let alone related. One with blue eyes and thick curly black hair and built like a swimmer/boxer, the other with limbs like matchsticks, white-blonde hair and brown eyes. They had trouble convincing the kids at school that they were sisters even though they had the same surname.

titianblue
titianblue
11 years ago

I’m a redhead. No way was my artistic mother putting me in pink.

kittehserf
11 years ago

And that’s my cue to show the pic I’ve been working on this evening.

(Hey, it’s clothing related, it’s almost relevant!)

Fibinachi
Fibinachi
11 years ago

Personally, I just want to take this moment to thank themaskandrose for not writing in this thread any more. All the not-writing he is currently doing in this thread is something I am very, very thankful for. His complete lack of writing anything here in the foreseeable future is, will be, and will remain, my favorite aspect of his absence from this thread.

Thank you, themaskandrose, for not participating in this conversation!

Huh
thanking people for things they aren’t doing kind of works…

Catfish
Catfish
11 years ago

Talking about ignoring “male protection” and other benefits (and “benefits”) that all women owe their lives for, what about the fact that a lot of the reasons humanity got where it is in the first place is because of unpaid labor and inventions made by women? Even today majority of the hard work is done by women and children. Generally as slave labor and/or or just for the sake of survival.

Not to mention a lot of the so called benefits that we “owe” for were only necessary in the first place because of the oppressive system.

It’s also kindova douchey move to describe some act in the past being something you owe either the ancestor or today’s equivalent group, because none of us asked to be born. Like, I shouldn’t have to owe someone for doing or not doing X when I had absolutely no knowledge or chance to impact said action in the first place.

Not that I might not be thankful for someone doing something at some point in time without my input, and not just to sound like I’m ungrateful. It’s just that I don’t think I should owe anyone anything just because they did something unrequested. It’s really situational to boot…

Know what I’m sayin’ ? 😛

Jodi
Jodi
11 years ago

@Fibinaci:

“I don’t go around demanding people thank for me for not dressing up as a hopskotch monster and dancing down the street singing “I’m a bee! I’m a bee!”.”

If you were to actually do this, it would make my day (maybe even my week or month). 🙂

Catfish
Catfish
11 years ago

Lego “Friends” it, to my knowledge, newer than the girl-directed Belleville legos from my childhood. Well, I didn’t actually have a single belleville set. My brother got tonnes of legos but we both played with them, and he didn’t mind sharing. He played with my toys too, but he tended to ruin them relatively often. Good thing my ponies were mostly knock-offs and not the real deal.
Belleville stuff was a lot bigger than the regular legos, so they weren’t really compatible.

My godmother got me a barbie almost every year. We barely saw each other, so I guess she just assumed that I liked them. I didn’t. I gave them all away or they were all broken some horrendous way – I did keep a horse that came with one of them though. I absolutely drowned in animal toys. Ponies, dinosaurs, stuffed animals… also aliens and the occasional Gojira and werewolf. Also, glow in the dark skeleton. And pokémon. Lots of pokémon. I still have most of my toys and all of my pokémon stuff is with me at my own home.
Like, my brother played with my barbie more whereas I never did. She was the lady his action man had to save. (All though he failed to save her most of the time lol)

I also had a make-up doll head, which me and my friends played with by grabbing her hair and throwing her around. It eventually got stuck in a tree and we never found it again o.o
Until some years back, my brother did, and we flung her around again. Flew in a tree, never came down.

I mean, my parents pretty much got me what every toy or thing I wanted at the time of my birthday. Relatives tended to get me stuffed animals no matter what, and I was perfectly happy with that.
All though it pissed me off to no end when my brother asked for video games, and nobody said anything against, but when I requested a videogame, they tended to ask “what would you do with that?”. PLAY IT, FUCKING DUH.

Catfish
Catfish
11 years ago

Ohh I was supposed to make a mention of my childhood internalized misogyny, dysphoria (which I still experience) and depression that was partly connected to all that but don’t want to steer more off topic than this crap all ready is 😛 Plus I managed to produce a wall of text even without that.

thenatfantastic
thenatfantastic
11 years ago

I gave them all away or they were all broken some horrendous way

When my middle sister and I were young we finally invented a game to play with our barbies. It involved sitting at the top of the loft ladder and conducting mock trials, then sentencing them to die in extremely nasty ways. If I recall correctly, we named it ‘Barbecue Pit’.

I would have made a fantastic despot.

Martin
Martin
11 years ago

I want to tell you how excellent you are, but I bet you hear that a lot. Seriously, you’re really funny and are performing a public service.

emilygoddess
emilygoddess
11 years ago

On the topic of increasingly gendered clothing and toys, folks might enjoy Peggy Orenstein’s Cinderella Ate My Daughter. I haven’t had the chance to read it yet, but I saw the author speak about it and she had some good things to say.

Argenti Aertheri
11 years ago

“I think my kids generation was the last where you could still dress babies in white and just add a ribbon or other sex identifying accessory.”

Maybe? I’m a year younger than your younger daughter and my mother says that’s what she did…minus the accessory, cuz who cares what gender people thought I was? (Sometimes, I swear, she rocks. I might have to actually deal with the family fallout of my non-binary gender if they expected me to give a single fuck about gender roles)

Shaun DarthBatman Day
11 years ago

I got very excited when I saw a pink “chemistry set”. Then I looked more closely, and realised it was for making cupcakes.

I fucking hate gender binary toy marketing. If a toy is operated by your genitalia, it is not for children.

Argenti Aertheri
11 years ago

Hey, I liked my turtle training potty! (Only acceptable genital operated toy for children, cuz I’m a, uh, smart ass…pun definitely not intended)

1 4 5 6 7 8 14