The gaming enthusiast known as seanmalstrom seems to be on a personal crusade to challenge the stereotype of men as the โlogical sex.โ He does this mostly by 1) being a dude and 2) writing things that make no sense at all.
In a recent post on his blog Malstromโs Articles News โ no, thatโs really what itโs called โ Mr. Malstrom attempts to rebut a piece by John Walker of the gaming site Rock Paper Shotgun that challenged misogyny in the gaming world.
Itโs not much of a rebuttal, but Mr. Malstrom makes a couple of, er, “arguments” that grabbed my attention. At one point he suggests that if game developers stop populating their games with sexy lady characters with giant boobs and long legs, American men will have no way to exercise their God-given right to ogle sexy ladies with giant boobs and long legs.
There is a great question I have yet to hear anyone in the Game Industry answer. If women cannot be depicted fantastical (big boobs, long legs, slaughters armies single-handedly) in fantasy entertainment, where can men go to see fantasy women? Women have their fantasy men from endless soap-operas, romance novels, chick flicks, and such. Are men not allowed to have fantasies in entertainment?
True, that is a question Iโve yet to see anyone in the game industry answer, largely because most of the people in the game industry, whatever their flaws, live in the real world, and in the real world images of sexy ladies with big boobs are not exactly difficult to come by.
Mr. Malstrom goes on to argue that men in the English-speaking world have the greatest need for sexy lady video game characters, because the women they run into on a regular basis in the real world are all fatties. In the Cold War era, politicians warned about a โMissile Gapโ with the Russians. Today, apparently, we and the Russians have a Fatty Gap.
In Russia, it is stunning to see alcoholic bums of Russian men with model quality looks Russian women. In the same way, in the United States it is stunning to see wealthy, hardworking, handsome American men with an American woman who looks like a Troglodyte. Of course, this is just a generalization. The point is that the typical American male has a better worldwide value if they stop thinking the local obese women around them are โthe normalโ. They arenโt the normal worldwide.
If anyone needs fantasy depictions, it would be English speaking men who donโt have access to the worldwide standard.
Mr. Malstrom is also bothered by the suggestion that video game makers should try to make female characters more interesting. You know, with personalities and motivations of their own, and stuff like that. To Mr. Malstrom, thereโs nothing more interesting about a women than her body.
What makes a woman interesting to men?
The truth is that interesting women needs youth, big boobs, long legs, long hair, and an hourglass figure to be interesting to men. The more women go away from this, the less interesting they become to men. This is why women when inevitably age, they become more and more invisible to men. It is just Nature at work. Ironically, for men the older they get, the more interesting they can become to women as their earning potential goes up. This balances out how most young men are invisible to women when they are younger. After the age of 25, men tend to become the more interesting ones compared to a woman of equal age. This is why mothers always advised their daughters to โsnag him when he and she are both youngโ.
Indeed, Mr. Malstrom argues, men who insist that women be depicted as sex objects are doing women a giant favor.
And we should only hope that women wish to be depicted as sex objects for that is how they become love objects as well. No man wants to marry a women they arenโt attracted to. Last I checked, marriage rates were plummeting in the West. Perhaps journalists should strive for โpositive changeโ by suggesting to women to be depicted more as sex objects so they can attract a man for marriage before they get too old. That would truly help women and make men happier as well.
Mr. Malstrom concludes with a stirring call for women to stop being such fat fatties.
It IS tasteless for using women as sex objects to sell games. Why? It is because real life women should be sex objects to begin with. If that were the case, putting them on a game cover wouldnโt be selling the game. This used to be the case decades ago. Since obesity in women have skyrocketed and attractive women have diminished, putting attractive women on game covers definitely attracts men more than it should.
It IS sad that women canโt find themselves sensibly portrayed in the games they play. It is not because the women in the games are โtoo attractiveโ, it is because the women playing them tend to be โtoo fatโ. It is sad for women that they are fat. It is also sad for men. What John Walker should do is to advise women to get in shape and try to look like the depictions of women that men are attracted to. This would be โpositive changeโ we could all get behind.
I hate to burst your bubble, Mr. Malstrom, but I donโt think there was any era of history in which women looked like this.
It’s probably just as well, as Lara here doesn’t seem to have eyelids and her head isn’t properly connected to her neck.
Note: Thanks to Tatjna for pointing me to Mr. Malstrom’s post!
@CassandraSays – wrong (on your assumptions about me).
@Cloudiah – you are. Wrong. And making shit up. Funnily enough, especially your quaint notion that I post here when drunk. Which I have never done. That’s just bullshit you make up in your head.
@Aaliyah – You prove my point, by missing it.
Here’s a challenge for you. Wait a few weeks. Create a male identified ID, with a Western name. Come into Manboobz and post the exact same points about Islam that you do now.
And watch the difference in reaction.
I honestly agree with Joe that many social justice spaces on the internet are full of very unreasonable Islam apologia (and absurd accusations of hating Muslims) – I just don’t have any reason to believe that this space in particular is like that, given that I have yet to receive any negative reactions for denouncing Islam. I’m sure things would be different if there were some Muslims here, but still…
Also, Joe, in spite of what I have stated, I have definitely noticed a lot of critics of Islam being prejudiced against all Muslims. Daniel Pipes is a good example IIRC. It’s certainly not unheard of. And I’m sick of it.
…He really doesn’t understand why Aaliyah* is a better authority on what it is like to be a woman in Islam, particularly a trans woman, than he is?
Joe really should look into a remedial reading program. His not knowing what things mean is embarrassing.
Wow, he’s like this sober too? At least my hypothetical ranting old man can use the bourbon as an excuse.
It’s more fun if I imagine Joe as a ranting old drunk. The alternative is too fucking sad.
That asterisk was supposed to go to a thing where I apologized to you, Aaliyah, for talking about you in the 3rd person a bunch.
I thought he was drunk posting too. Otherwise there is no excuse for his behavior.
Uh, all he needs in order to be a reliable authority of Islam is to understand it. He doesn’t have to be an trans* female apostate like me. If you read my journal entries, you will see that I criticize Islam primarily because I find its teachings reprehensible. Of course, I have personal problems with Islam as well, but they are mostly irrelevant when it comes to critiquing the morality of Islam’s teachings themselves.
I guess I can have a more informed and clearer perspective as a trans* woman, but that’s it.
Joe thinks criticism of Islam is all the one thing, whether it’s someone who’s lived it saying “This is the treatment I have had, these are the teachings that treatment was based on, there’s a systemic problem here and yeah, I hate it!” or the likes of Owly running around screeching “All the Muslims are terrorists and evil and they marry ten year olds and blow up buildings all the time and it’s a plot against ‘Murrica ‘cos of that Kenyan Muslim in the White [Man’s] House!”
… I think [B]ourbon is a great excuse for lots of things. ๐
@First Joe:
I just had like, three shots of G&T… but I’m pretty sure what I wrote was:
Like, that… that’s not watering anything down. The reason for my hatred is that I’m taking severe offense at this verse here. And there. And there. But okay. Sure. I don’t understand! But then again, I’m a lizard person.
So It’s not like I can understand.
http://i1311.photobucket.com/albums/s669/HuddiBras2/LIZARDFIBIDOESNTGETIT_zps572e6af7.jpg
Sigh.
Right now my most significant feeling about bourbon is that it’s about time for it to start showing up in desserts. There’s this place that makes the most awesome lemon sorbet flavored with bourbon.
Sorry, I wasn’t trying to dismiss where you were coming from Aaliyah as far as learning about Islam. For what it’s worth, I don’t think Joe knows a damned thing about Islam except that it’s largely practiced by people of colour from parts of the world that are foreign to him.
It’s no problem, Viscaria! I didn’t take any offense to anything you’ve said in this thread. =]
Joe, your motivations are baffling to me. You’ve declared your disdain for this community before, so there’s nothing to be gained by repeating yourself; this community has declared its disdain for you before, so you aren’t likely to find an ally (and, really, if you just want to find some racist buddies for Islam-bashing, you could probably be more successful elsewhere). So why show up and derail a thread, pre-emptively declare everyone here to be a hypocrite, and then stand around lauding yourself for an invented victory? Like, really, is this satisfying to you?
P.S. In keeping with my personal custom when responding to you, I would like to remind you that you’re a racist asshole. Have a nice day.
I am not drinking tonight, since I am super sad and stressed and given the alcoholism in my family, I try to avoid using alcohol to help me through hard times. I was thinking about stress-eating until my stomach explodes… which is possibly a healthier coping strategy?
Viscaria: taking a hot bath (not too hot!)? Snuggling a kitty?
I’m sorry you’re in a bad place tonight.
Sorry, I went to a whinier place than I meant to XD what I meant to say was “your many drink ideas sound tempting but I am thinking I should ignore that temptation” rather than “woe is me! Bring me all of your pities!!”
I am snuggling two kitties. They are jerks and keep trying to chew my knitting and my power cords. I keep threatening to replace them with robokitties but they do not seem worried.
How about giving yourself a tryotophan rush? Turkey, hot milk, etc.
Once affordable, realistic robokitties are available to the average pet owner, real kitties — and their unrealistic demands for food and love and care — will become obsolete! Naturally, this will result in kitties and humans choosing to separate from one another by living on opposite sides of the Mississippi river.
I’m gonna put away the tortilla chips and pull out the chamomile ๐
Hugs, Viscaria. Evil, bitter, feminist hugs. ๐
And if Joe1 isn’t drunk, that is just so sad. ๐
He doesn’t seem to appreciate the fact that we were giving him the benefit of the doubt by assuming that nobody would post things that ranty and idiotic if they were sober.